Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
Cafe Amici in Wyckoff
Open
11:00 am
Monday
11:00 am
Wednesday
11:00 am
Friday
11:00 am
Sunday
11:00 am
315 Franklin Ave, Wyckoff, NJ 07481-2096
Privilege
Cuisine
- American
- Italian
- Gluten Free Options
- Vegetarian Friendly
- Vegan Options
Features
- Takeout
- Seating
- Waitstaff
- Reservations
- Parking Available
- Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
- Families witd children
- Kids
- Local cuisine
Privilege
Cuisine
- American
- Italian
- Gluten Free Options
- Vegetarian Friendly
- Vegan Options
Features
- Takeout
- Seating
- Waitstaff
- Reservations
- Parking Available
- Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
- Families witd children
- Kids
- Local cuisine
Questions and answers
Reviews
JK
11/02/2024
On google
Jimmy Katayama
So tonight i ordered the vegetarian plate . HORRIBLE!! we been coming here for a while but this plate or dish that was made on monday 22 april was totally unexceptable!!
More
JR
08/17/2020
On google
J R
Cafa amici has a good menu with food for everyone. But it lacks in service when I went to eat brunch and it took 20 minutes to get a waiter and it took even longer to get a food order. I ordered Belgium Waffles and they came overdone. My brother had a hair in his food.
More
cs
08/17/2020
On google
corey stramiello
the food was incredible. we went for Christmas eve dinner. I had the prime rib and others had the prime filet with lobster mashed. Delicious. Will definitely be back.
More
MB
08/17/2020
On google
Matt B
1st time there amazing. Nice small local place
TW
08/17/2020
On google
Thomas Weir
Great salads and excellent coffee. Friendly staff, and clean facility. Desserts look incredible, honestly just a fantastic place.
More
JM
08/17/2020
On google
John Marsch
My go to Italian restaurant. Food is always amazing. The specials menu is constantly being updated. Food is sourced locally. Prices are in the range of any Wyckoff restaurant. Service is spot on. They do not take reservations and gets busy during normal dinner hours.
More
ka
08/17/2020
On google
kurt alter
Delicious scallops with corn risotto avocado cream & microgreens
gh
08/17/2020
On google
graeme hill
Small, so a little noisy...food menu varied and great quality.enjoyed the meal and relaxed ambience
More
JW
08/17/2020
On google
John Warnet
I do a lot of take out from. Cafe Amici. Never had a bad dish but the pastas are the best.
More
EO
08/17/2020
On google
Entertainment On Wheels
Always have a great experience at Cafe Amici. Love the pizza especially. Huge fan of prosciutto cooked on my pizza.
More
BA
08/17/2020
On google
Bobby Arutt
Great spot. Food is tasty and fresh. Brent the owner is a really nice guy. Small cozy restaurant.
More
DD
08/17/2020
On google
Debbie Duffy
Went here on a Sunday afternoon and was so disappointed in the serviceThe morning staff served us and then left. The evening staff arrived and was holding conversation and setting up the tables and conversing around and over us like we weren't even there. We were completely ignored. No refills for tea or lemonade without asking and receiving a face.Tried to get the check to leave and no one was paying attention. Finally asked if it was ok for us to leave and that's when the bill was brought over.Asked for remain of our food to be wrapped and had to chase the waitress for our food she started to take care of the people arriving for dinner.THIS WAS THE WORST SERVICE EVER RECEIVEDALSO BE CAREFUL AND SAVE YOUR CHARGE RECEIPTS. I WAS ONCE CHARGED MORE THAN I SIGNED FOR. CALL FOR A CORRECTION AND MANAGEMENT DID NOTHING. GOT CREDIT FROM AMEX.
More
mw
08/17/2020
On google
mitzi westermeyer
Excellent Wait Staff service
PW
08/17/2020
On google
Parker Wilson
Dear people who have a lot of time on your hands. Cafe Amici, has bad service. There was also a hair in my food. In the end of the order, when we had the check, they charged for 2 of 1 thing. Which we told them before, they messed up. It took us 20 minutes to at least to get a hold of a waiter. To all my fellow people who want to eat at this Cafe, do yourself a favor and don’t come to this Cafe.
More
JS
08/17/2020
On google
Joseph S
Great food and service. Inside is a little small so you might want to call in and make reservations. I had the fried calamari which was delicious and the burger. All of the wait staff was very helpful and had smiles on. I felt right at home in this establishment. Next time we are in the mood for good italian we will be back.
More
RL
08/17/2020
On google
Rich Laubsch
Food was good but not worth any wait
DB
08/17/2020
On google
Debbi Baumgartner
Absolutely delicious meal every time! Fresh quality ingredients and staff are always friendly and attentive!
More
JC
08/17/2020
On google
Josiah Chung
A busy crowd esp for lunch. Good food and service was great!
MP
08/17/2020
On google
Meli Pura Vida
This place has got the best food ever. Fantastic flavors. I come here often for lunch. A must try. The pizza is better than i assumed it would be
More
AB
08/17/2020
On google
Alex Bachrach
Cafe Amici is basically five-star food without the high prices, in a family setting with food for everyone. But the specials are as good as any restaurant in NYC or anywhere and the chef is world-class. Can’t beat this place, regardless of price.
More
NA
08/17/2020
On google
Nathan Amitai
Tasty food and friendly staff. BYOB
DL
08/17/2020
On google
Dean Laforgia
At first impression I thought it was a little pricey but then realized it is BYOB so that makes up for the price. Cafe is is furnished in a tasteful Manner and the food is excellent! I had a beet salad with goat cheese and a rack of lamb both were delicious. The atmosphere is smart casual and not too loud for a nice dinner. Some restaurants can become very noisy but this one appeared to be just right. The service was very good, my waitress was very attentive.
More
KC
08/17/2020
On google
Kelly Coogan
It doesn't have much of a selection to eat and is quite pricey for its meals.
EK
08/17/2020
On google
Erika Kao
This is one of my favorite local restaurants. The food is consistently good, plus it's healthy and they get it locally when they can. Staff is always helpful. The noise from other tables does tend to carry, so it is not what I would call a quiet place, but it's never been an issue for me. Love it here.
More
JB
08/17/2020
On google
Jim Barry
Excellent . You must try the godfather
DG
08/17/2020
On google
David Glaser
This place is the best. The food is of the highest quality purveyed from local farms.The menu is diverse and delicious.For dinner, you could have a burger for $13 or fresh fish for $27 so there is much choice.While sometimes there's a wait for tables, the service is always accommodating and friendly. If there is a better restaurant in Bergen County, I have yet to find it.
More
AF
08/17/2020
On google
Andre Floyd
Usually pretty good. Last night was just average. Still, it is BYO.
MT
08/17/2020
On google
Matt Taylor
This place always has great food. It can get busy at times so check the current status, but even if you have to wait it will be worth it. The Ahi Tuna salad is really good!
More
SW
08/17/2020
On google
Sue Willemann
The specials are always fantastic. Fresh and innovative.
CM
08/17/2020
On google
Craig McKim
Great food. Good service. Usually crowded. Must try restaurant!!
JD
08/17/2020
On google
Jess Dogali
Food was not good. Service was extremely slow.
MH
08/17/2020
On google
Marina Hadjichristou
Delicious food, great atmosphere and friendly staff! We randomly found this cute cafe but we are definitely going back!
More
JB
08/17/2020
On google
Judith Berkey
Bob great food and casual dining Always a hit
BN
08/17/2020
On google
Brendan Nagle
Amazing food and service!
TK
08/17/2020
On google
Tapan Katwala
The food is always consistently good here.
AD
08/17/2020
On google
Allison DiNapoli
Food was ok. Service was ok.
FP
08/17/2020
On google
Fred Puccio
The ahi tuna salad was awesome!
SW
08/17/2020
On google
Shirl Winkelman
Food very good, but takes forever to get your order. Must have alot of time
DR
08/17/2020
On google
David Radney
Love the staff and everything I've tasted on the menu so far
MN
08/17/2020
On google
Mark Nouhan
Great in town spot! BYOB! Great variety on the menu!
FH
08/17/2020
On google
Florence H
I love the food here! Everything I've had so far has been delicious, though service can sometimes be slow on Sundays right after noon.
More
AW
08/17/2020
On google
Althea Wood
Extremely busy and waited a long time for our entrees, but the servers were very nice, enjoyed the ambience and my meal. The Wellfleet Oysters were some of the best oysters I've ever had and the fish oil/ wine / ginger sauce served with them was phenomenal. I never order chicken out, but tonight I did and, again, was not disappointed.
More
JG
08/17/2020
On google
Jennifer Gareffa
We eat here often, at least once a month & we alternate taking out & dining in. We chose to dine there tonight (a Saturday night) & at 5:20pm we were told there would be a 25 min wait. We had a bottle of wine, but no one offered to open it for us, nor did anyone give us glasses so my husband helped himself to the wine opener AND glasses. 40 min later when our table was ready, the hostess calls us to our table & we have to carry our open wine bottle & wine glasses to the table ourselves. Not a very welcome or accommodating vibe. The chicken scarpiello was burnt & the swordfish had a very fishy smell. I had to dowse it in lemon. On our way out, the hostess ignored us after dropping $100- no thank you, no good- bye, no see you soon. Guess what?! You won’t!
More
CH
08/17/2020
On google
Craig Heller
Great food abounds with wonderful service. A joyful eating experience with each visit.
More
EB
08/17/2020
On google
Elisa Borowski
Very cute and cozy spot. The food is locally sourced which is great and it tasted great!
More
CW
08/17/2020
On google
Craig Wilkes
I love this place!!! my friend went there once
GH
08/17/2020
On google
Graeme Hill
I have always enjoyed my visits here... Relaxed and the food is fresh and vibrant
More
cs
08/17/2020
On google
carole stoll
Excellent food and EXTREMELY attentive servers!!!! We come here all the time. 5 Stars for a delicious local restaurant. Owner very attentive, as well...
More
SR
08/17/2020
On google
Suzanne Rosenhaus
Always very goodService wonderfulEven with the restraints of covid 19 outdoor restaurantNicely done and well organizedBravo
More